New Bankruptcy Law ? Targeting the Wrong People?

Last April, President Bush enthusiastically signed into law the oddly-named Bankruptcy Abuse and Consumer Protection Act. This bill, representing the biggest overhaul of bankruptcy law in twenty-five years, was written in order to discourage "bankruptcy of convenience." Proponents of the bill, which included the credit card industry, say that the bill is necessary in order to stop an avalanche of bankruptcy filings by drug users and compulsive shoppers and gamblers. The law makes it harder to have debts wiped away, requires credit counseling for those considering bankruptcy, and holds attorneys responsible for paperwork errors by their clients in bankruptcy cases. The net result will probably be chaos, as fewer attorneys will handle bankruptcy cases, credit counselors will raise their fees, and more consumers with problem debt will be clueless as to what they should do next. Adding to the confusion are some new statistics that suggest that a large number of bankruptcies that are thought to be personal are actually business bankruptcies. As a result, the new law may be unfairly targeting consumers for punishment when they are not actually the biggest part of the problem. Worse, it could be harming small businesses.

Studies suggest that the number of business bankruptcies may actually be up to ten times higher than previously reported. Many small businesses that fail and file for bankruptcy do so under guidelines that technically classify them as personal bankruptcies. The new law doesn't account for this, however, and treats such bankruptcy filers no differently than those who file because they can't stop shopping. It benefits no one to force a small store owner to undergo mandatory credit counseling when their business may have failed due to other reasons, such as having a big-box retailer more in next door. Even if that is the case, the law will require the bankrupt business owner to attend counseling in order to learn about managing personal and household budgets. This wastes the time of both the business owner and the credit-counseling agency and denies valuable counseling resources to those people who may really need it.

In time, Congress may amend this legislation if certain aspects of it do not work as intended. In the meantime, small business owners and those with personal debt problems will be inconvenienced, credit counseling agencies will be overworked, and no one will be any better off for it.

©Copyright 2005 by Retro Marketing. Charles Essmeier is the owner of Retro Marketing, a firm devoted to informational Websites, including End-Your-Debt.com, a site devoted to debt consolidation and credit counseling, and HomeEquityHelp.com, a site devoted to information regarding home equity loans.

Related News

At meeting of governors, state leaders press Obama for federal ... - Dallas Morning News Washington Post At meeting of governors, state leaders press Obama for federal ... Dallas Morning News, TX -19 hours ago And the governor urged Mr. Obama to revamp FEMA, so that it will dispense funds to states rather than manage disaster relief directly. ... What shape will stimulus take?Laconia Citizen In US, State Governments Want $176 Billion Slice Of Stimulus MoneyFree Internet Press For Obama, it's govs at first sightKDBC all 2,314 news articles Hawaiian Telcom Gets Court Authority to Use $75 million Cash ... - MarketWatch Hawaiian Telcom Gets Court Authority to Use $75 million Cash ... MarketWatch -4 hours ago Hawaiian Telcom and certain of its subsidiaries filed for relief under Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code in the US Bankruptcy Court for the District of ... Obama pledges relief to governors - The News Journal Obama pledges relief to governors The News Journal, DE -10 hours ago "We don't believe economic problems that were in large measure created by too much debt will be solved by more debt," Sanford said Tuesday. ". ... GM, Chrysler Win Union Concessions to Bolster Aid Bid (Update3) - Bloomberg Boston Globe GM, Chrysler Win Union Concessions to Bolster Aid Bid (Update3) Bloomberg -2 hours ago GM had its rating on $43 billion of debt cut to Ca, the second-lowest grade, from Caa2 by Moody's Investors Service today. Chrysler's credit rating was also ... Video: UAW Offers Help To Big ThreeCBS GM's Henderson says UAW talks ongoingDetNews.com US car union makes concessionsFinancial Times all 1,500 news articles Holders deem Station Casinos bond offer "deficient" - Reuters Holders deem Station Casinos bond offer "deficient" Reuters -6 hours ago The new debt is being offered at a significant discount to par, with senior note holders being offered $540 per $1000 in debt and subordinated note holders ... Andhra pays for fiscal profligacy, may be denied debt relief - Economic Times Andhra pays for fiscal profligacy, may be denied debt relief Economic Times, India -Dec 1, 2008 In FY08, the state got a debt-relief of around Rs 1889 crore. “We have been attaining a revenue surplus despite huge allocations for revenue expenditure ... Know the Details of the Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act - RisMedia.com (press release) Know the Details of the Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act RisMedia.com (press release), CT -Dec 1, 2008 ... in December 2007, Congress stepped in to provide temporary relief in the form of forgiving this debt, but only for the 2007, 2008 and 2009 tax years. ... UPDATE 1-Pininfarina sees agreement with banks by end-2008 - Reuters Calgary Herald UPDATE 1-Pininfarina sees agreement with banks by end-2008 Reuters -5 hours ago MI: Quote, Profile, Research, Stock Buzz) is also in talks with its main creditor, Royal Bank of Scotland, to gain relief from its 3 billion euro debt. ... Europe stocks rise as buoyant pharmas offset minersReuters all 1,656 news articles Paulson Considers New Plan to Lower Mortgage Rates (Update3) - Bloomberg CNBC Paulson Considers New Plan to Lower Mortgage Rates (Update3) Bloomberg -3 hours ago He first resisted, then accepted, foreclosure relief as part of the $168 billion economic-stimulus package passed in February. House prices in 20 US cities ... A Rush Into Refinancing as Mortgage Rates FallNew York Times Mortgage applications up 112.1% last week, due to drop in rates: MBAMarketWatch US working on affordable mortgage plan: sourcesReuters New York Times Blogs - Telegraph.co.uk all 313 news articles Firms Seek More Action to Unfreeze Lending - Wall Street Journal Firms Seek More Action to Unfreeze Lending Wall Street Journal -7 hours ago So far, the Treasury's Troubled Asset Relief Program, or TARP, and Fed programs to ease the financial crunch have focused on banks and, more recently, ...