New Bankruptcy Law ? Where?s the Consumer Protection?


On April 20, 2005, President Bush signed into law the Bankruptcy Abuse and Consumer Protection Act, a piece of sweeping legislation that brought about the most sweeping changes in personal bankruptcy law in the last quarter century. This bill, which takes effect in October 2005, passed with the overwhelming support of both parties of congress, claims, through its very name, to offer "consumer protection." Does it? How are consumers "protected" by this bill?

The purpose of the new legislation, is to eliminate "bankruptcy of convenience". Sponsors of the bill allege that most consumer bankruptcy cases involve irresponsible spenders who have shopped or gambled their money away and now do not wish to pay their creditors. They rightly point out that bankruptcy costs the credit card companies billions of dollars each year and that those costs are passed on to consumers in the form of higher interest rates. By making it harder for those with problem debt to file for bankruptcy, legislators say that more people will pay their bills, the credit card companies will save billions of dollars, and the resulting savings will be passed on to consumers in the form of lower interest rates.

The bill is lengthy, but key points are as follows:

  • Those considering bankruptcy will have to pass a "means test." If their income is above a certain threshold, they will not be able to file under Chapter 7 of the Federal bankruptcy code, which wipes out debt and gives the debtor a fresh start. Instead, they will have to file under Chapter 13, which establishes a five year repayment plan.
  • There are no provisions in the law for debt problems caused by job loss, illness or other traumatic events, despite studies that show that these are the cause of most bankruptcy cases.
  • Attorneys will now be responsible for the accuracy of paperwork filed by their clients. This will probably result in fewer bankruptcy attorneys, with those that continue to practice raising their fees substantially in order to offset their additional liability.
  • In short, most consumers are no longer protected from job loss or illness by being able to file under Chapter 7 and they will have less help from competent attorneys due to the new liability provision of the bill. There is little to "protect" consumers in the Bankruptcy Abuse and Consumer Protection Act. The sole benefit for consumers resulting from this bill will be lower interest rates and fees from the credit card companies, who will save billions of dollars as a result of this legislation. Of course, should the credit card companies choose to keep the savings, rather than pass them on to their customers, then consumers will be left with no benefit or "protection" at all.

    Copyright 2005 by Retro Marketing.

    Charles Essmeier is the owner of Retro Marketing, a firm devoted to informational Websites, including End-Your-Debt.com, a site devoted to debt consolidation and credit counseling, and HomeEquityHelp.com, a site devoted to information regarding home equity loans.







    Related News



    UPDATE 1-Pininfarina sees agreement with banks by end-2008 - Reuters

    Calgary Herald

    UPDATE 1-Pininfarina sees agreement with banks by end-2008
    Reuters -5 hours ago
    MI: Quote, Profile, Research, Stock Buzz) is also in talks with its main creditor, Royal Bank of Scotland, to gain relief from its 3 billion euro debt. ...
    Europe stocks rise as buoyant pharmas offset minersReuters
    all 1,656 news articles

    Know the Details of the Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act - RisMedia.com (press release)

    Know the Details of the Mortgage Forgiveness Debt Relief Act
    RisMedia.com (press release), CT -Dec 1, 2008
    ... in December 2007, Congress stepped in to provide temporary relief in the form of forgiving this debt, but only for the 2007, 2008 and 2009 tax years. ...

    Six financial gifts that let you do more with less this season - MarketWatch

    Six financial gifts that let you do more with less this season
    MarketWatch -23 hours ago
    That said, I think that providing some debt relief to your loved ones is different. You're using the money that would have gone to a traditional gift, ...

    C& subsidiaries granted debt relief - 중앙데일리

    C& subsidiaries granted debt relief
    중앙데일리, South Korea -12 hours ago
    Creditors yesterday agreed on a debt workout program requested by the companies. The market has closely watched the shipbuilding and construction arms of ...

    HIPC: Togo Gets Debt Relief - THISDAY

    HIPC: Togo Gets Debt Relief
    THISDAY, Nigeria -Nov 30, 2008
    The statement said that Togo would receive interim debt relief from certain creditors, but in order to qualify for irrevocable debt relief at the completion ...

    Firms Seek More Action to Unfreeze Lending - Wall Street Journal

    Firms Seek More Action to Unfreeze Lending
    Wall Street Journal -7 hours ago
    So far, the Treasury's Troubled Asset Relief Program, or TARP, and Fed programs to ease the financial crunch have focused on banks and, more recently, ...

    Home > News > World Bank Launches Facility to Prevent ... - World Bank Group

    Home > News > World Bank Launches Facility to Prevent ...
    World Bank Group, DC -Nov 30, 2008
    The Bank also called on donor countries to meet their debt relief commitments. “The debt relief provided by the World Bank and other creditors to heavily ...


    Andhra pays for fiscal profligacy, may be denied debt relief - Economic Times

    Andhra pays for fiscal profligacy, may be denied debt relief
    Economic Times, India -Dec 1, 2008
    In FY08, the state got a debt-relief of around Rs 1889 crore. “We have been attaining a revenue surplus despite huge allocations for revenue expenditure ...

    Togo qualifies for debt relief - afrol News

    Togo qualifies for debt relief
    afrol News, Lesotho -Dec 2, 2008
    afrol News, 2 December - Togo has been approved for debt relief under enhanced Heavily Indebted Poor Countries, after reaching a decision point under the ...

    Obama pledges relief to governors - The News Journal

    Obama pledges relief to governors
    The News Journal, DE -10 hours ago
    "We don't believe economic problems that were in large measure created by too much debt will be solved by more debt," Sanford said Tuesday. ". ...